PMI Article: Implementing the CMA Orders

DB trustee boards are not lazy or stupid, but for too long they have been starved of the necessary information and insights to make effective investment decisions...

Click here to read the full article. 


If you are a member of the PMI, click here to check out the full magazine

Press Release: Investment consultants agree to discuss IC Select solution in drive for transparency

London,2 October 2018 – the Big Three investment consultants - Aon, Mercer and Willis Towers Watson - have agreed to take part in top-level talks, hosted by governance specialist IC Select, to develop a strategy to show whether they provide value for money to their advisory pension scheme clients.


The other consultants who have so far agreed to participate in the first round of talks are Cardano, KPMG, Redington, River and Mercantile, and Momentum. Discussions with further firms are ongoing.

Continue reading

Press Release: CMA Report Response

CMA Report marks turning point in drive for transparency and good governance


London, 18th July 2018  – Advisory firm IC Select welcomes the CMA provisional decision report and support the decision not to split up the investment consultants which we felt would have been detrimental to the investment services that many pension funds receive from them.

Peter Dorward, Managing Director, IC Select, commented: “Overall we believe the report and the process of discussion with the industry has changed attitudes towards transparency for the better by investment consultants and fiduciary managers. The remedies proposed will ensure that as the process moves forward from here, these transparency gains are not lost”.

Continue reading

Press Release: Third party evaluators back Fiduciary Performance Standard

London, 1 June 2018 – Third party evaluators of fiduciary management Barnett Waddingham, Hymans Robertson, IC Select, KPMG, Lane Clark & Peacock and XPS Investment have backed the Fiduciary Management Performance Standard.


They believe that all Fiduciary Managers should have the capability to comply with the standard, or explain why this is not the case.


Mallowstreet, the social network for pension schemes, recently asked their membership whether trustees need a fiduciary management performance standard. The result was 100% in favour - a rare consensus.

Continue reading

Press Release: Investment consultant tenders in sharp decline


Investment Consultant Tenders in Sharp Decline

London, 21 May 2018 – Around 2.7% of pension schemes retendered for investment consulting services in 2017 – less than a sixth the proportion of a decade ago - according to a survey of 1,000 schemes, worth £697 billion, by oversight and selection specialist IC Select.

This is a marginal increase on the 2.5% of 2016 and 1.6% of 2015.  But these proportions mark a sharp decline on 18.6% of 2008. Retenders have been bumping along at a low level over the three years despite growing scrutiny of investment consultant expertise and questions over the level of tender activity.

IC Select’s survey of schemes on their database also showed 1.5% of schemes ended up changing their consultant, against 11% in 2008, marking a steady decline over ten years. The changes stripped out scheme mergers, and entries into the Pension Protection Fund.

Peter Dorward, managing director of IC Select, said: “It is surprising the level of tender activity over the last three years has been so low. This follows the spread of de-risking plans, which has added to the complexity of investment affairs and, potentially, ties schemes more closely to incumbent advisers.”

Continue reading